KKoumen Tools PRO

Dividend reinvestment — what the extra shares are worth.

Two portfolios, same stock, same start. One spends the dividend, one buys more shares with it.

$
$
%
%

The dividend per share grows once a year. Shares bought during a year start paying in the next one.

Reinvested after 20 years
$137,341
Reinvested$137,341
Dividend as cash$73,768
Difference+$63,573

Price growth and dividend growth are steady averages. Real prices do not move in a straight line.

YearDividendShares boughtReinvested valueCash plan valueCash received

How the two columns are built

Both starting positions are 500 shares of a stock trading at $40, so both cost $20,000. The dividend is $0.60 a share paid four times a year, which is $2.40 a year at the start, or a 6.0% yield. The share price is assumed to rise 3% a year and the dividend 4.5% a year, which is roughly what a mature, dividend-raising company has managed over long periods — not a promise, just a steady middle case to make the comparison readable.

The left-hand plan reinvests every payment. Each quarter it divides the dividend by the share price at that moment and buys the result, fractions included. Those new shares pay dividends from the following year. The right-hand plan does nothing with the money: share count stays at 500, the price still rises, and the dividends accumulate as cash you have to place somewhere.

At the end of year one the reinvested plan has 530.0 shares worth $21,836; the cash plan has its original 500 shares worth $20,600 and $1,200 in dividends in hand. The gap on day one is $36, and it stays small for years. That is the whole point of the exercise.

Worked example, taken through to year twenty

End of yearReinvested sharesReinvested valueCash plan valueCash received by then
1530.0$21,836$21,800$1,200
5674.7$31,288$29,750$6,565
10930.5$50,023$41,624$14,746
151,313.6$81,860$56,100$24,941
201,901.1$137,341$73,768$37,646

Two things are happening at once. The dividend per share has grown from $2.40 to $5.79 a year over the twenty years, and the share count has grown from 500 to 1,901. Multiply those two and the yearly payout has gone from $1,200 to $9,759. On the original $20,000 that is a yield on cost of 48.8%, against 13.8% for the plan that spent the cash.

Note the ordering in the table. Notice how slowly the gap opens. Reinvesting is ahead by $36 at the end of year one, $1,537 at the end of year five, $8,399 at the end of year ten, and $63,573 at the end of year twenty. Nothing about the first year feels like a decision worth making. The whole advantage sits in the last five years, which is why a DRIP only pays off for someone who actually holds.

What actually drives the answer

Where the arithmetic goes wrong in practice

Reading the yield-on-cost number honestly

Yield on cost is a popular figure because it flatters a long-held position: 48.8% sounds like an income stream nobody else can buy. It is not. The market values those shares at the current yield, which is still 6% of today's $72.24 price, and what you gave up to get there is the dividend cash you chose not to spend. The number worth comparing is the total: $137,341 against $73,768, before whatever you would have earned on the cash.

If each dividend went into a savings account at 3.5% and stayed there, the cash plan finishes around $100,800 instead of $73,768 — the gap narrows to roughly $36,500 but does not close. If the cash paid down a credit card at 22%, reinvesting looks like the worse decision. Run your own numbers rather than trusting the headline.

Questions

What is yield on cost and why does it grow so fast?

Yield on cost is the current yearly dividend divided by what you originally paid. It grows for two reasons at once: the company raises the dividend, and reinvestment buys more shares. In the worked example the starting yield is 6.0% on a $20,000 outlay; after twenty years the yearly dividend is $9,759, which is 48.8% of that same $20,000. Nothing about the stock changed to make that happen — you simply own 1,901 shares instead of 500.

Is DRIP growth the same as total return?

No. Total return with dividends reinvested equals price growth plus dividend yield, roughly. This calculator tracks the position — shares, share price and dividend rate — so it shows the outcome of two different decisions. It does not model dividends reinvested outside the position, and it does not include new money added later.

Do fractional shares matter to the answer?

They change it by a rounding error. With a $7,500 quarterly dividend against a $42 share price you buy 178.57 shares. Brokers that only allow whole shares leave $24 in cash, about 0.1% of that year's dividend. Over twenty years the difference is under half a percent of the final value.

How are dividends taxed when they are reinvested?

In a taxable account, reinvested dividends are still taxable in the year they are paid, even though you never saw the cash. The broker adds the reinvested amount to your cost basis, which reduces the capital gain when you sell. Inside a tax-sheltered account none of this applies and reinvestment is clean.

Why does the cash side still hold 500 shares after twenty years?

Because taking the dividend as income does not buy anything. The share count stays fixed while the price grows. The cash figure is the sum of all dividends received, undated and uninvested — if you put that money to work the comparison improves, and that is the number to weigh against the reinvested total.

More money tools

All money tools →

No daily limit on this tool

This one is free with no counter — the arithmetic runs in your browser and nothing is sent anywhere. All-Access is for the PDF and image tools, which are free three runs a day.