Every cost of owning against the rent you would pay instead, including the return you give up on the deposit.
Insurance is inflated at 2.5% a year. Everything else follows the rates above, compounded monthly.
Net cost means everything paid out, minus what the house is worth after commission, against rent paid minus investment gains on the money you kept.
The break-even year is the first year in which selling the house leaves you with more money than never buying it would have. It is not the year the mortgage is paid off, and it is not the year your equity passes some round number. It is the year one household's balance sheet overtakes the other's, with the house sold and the loan cleared.
Both sides are built the same way: total out, minus what comes back. The buying line adds the deposit, the closing costs, every mortgage payment, property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA dues, then subtracts the sale price net of commission and the outstanding loan. The renting line adds the rent paid and subtracts the investment gains on the money that was never tied up — the deposit, and the monthly difference between owning and renting. Whichever line is lower at year N is the cheaper way to have housed yourself for N years.
That structure is why the answer is not obvious from the two monthly payments. A mortgage payment is mostly interest at the start and mostly principal at the end, while rent is pure spending from the first month to the last. The payments can look similar for a decade while the two balance sheets move in opposite directions.
Ten percent down is $45,000, and 2.5% closing costs add $11,250, so the buyer needs $56,250 in cash on day one. The loan is $405,000 at 6.4% over thirty years: $2,533.30 a month of principal and interest, of which only $373.30 touches the balance in month one. The other $2,160.00 is interest.
Add property tax at 1.1% of value ($412.50 a month), insurance at $2,400 a year ($200), and upkeep at 1% of value ($375), and the first month of owning costs $3,520.80 against $2,750 of rent. The buyer is $770.80 a month worse off in cash and $56,250 worse off on the day of completion.
Owning still wins, in year six. Equity reaches $164,986 by then, and after a 6% commission the cheque at closing is $132,746. Rent for the same six years comes to $219,601 against a net cost of owning of $183,369 — a difference of $3,761, and that is the whole margin at the crossing point. Move out a year earlier and the renter is $5,697 ahead instead.
| Years held | Buying, net cost | Renting, net cost | Cheaper by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | $112,527 | $91,101 | Rent, $21,426 |
| 5 | $160,177 | $154,480 | Rent, $5,697 |
| 6 | $183,369 | $187,130 | Buy, $3,761 |
| 7 | $206,103 | $220,505 | Buy, $14,402 |
| 10 | $271,257 | $325,692 | Buy, $54,435 |
| 15 | $367,572 | $523,058 | Buy, $155,486 |
The buying line flattens because the mortgage payment is fixed while the loan shrinks and the house grows; the renting line steepens because rent compounds at 3.5% and, from about year ten, overtakes the monthly cost of owning. That is the whole mechanism. Nothing about owning gets cheaper — the payment simply stops rising.
Each row below is the same house with one assumption changed, recomputed by the tool. The spread from year four to year twelve is the honest range of this decision: a difference in rate or rent of a few hundred dollars is worth more than years of debate.
| One change from the example | Break-even |
|---|---|
| Mortgage rate 6.4% → 7.4% | year 10 |
| Mortgage rate 6.4% → 5.4% | year 4 |
| House growth 3% → 2% | year 10 |
| House growth 3% → 4% | year 4 |
| Rent $2,750 → $2,400 | year 12 |
| Rent $2,750 → $3,000 | year 4 |
| Selling costs 6% → 8% | year 7 |
| Investment return 6% → 8% | year 8 |
| Upkeep 1% → 1.5% of value | year 8 |
Two of those rows deserve attention. A single point of mortgage rate is worth four years of break-even here, because the rate multiplies a $405,000 balance. And a 20% lower rent moves the answer six years later without touching the house at all — which is why the same property can be a good buy for one person and a bad one for another, purely on what the rental alternative costs them.
Under five years is comfortable: you keep a margin if you move sooner than planned. Five to eight years is the normal range for a house bought with 10–20% down at mortgage rates around 6%, held long enough for a fixed payment to fall behind rising rent. Past ten years, renting usually wins unless the rent on an equivalent house is within about 20% of the all-in cost of owning, which happens in metros where price-to-rent ratios run above 25.
Because it scales both columns. More down means a smaller loan and less interest, but also more capital that could have been earning a return somewhere else. At 10% and 20% down on the example above, the break-even lands in the same year, while the month-one payment falls by about $280 and the cash needed on the day of purchase rises by $45,000. The deposit changes what you can afford and how much risk you carry, not which option is cheaper.
No, and for most buyers in the United States that omission is closer to correct than it used to be. The standard deduction absorbs the interest on a loan of this size for a married couple filing jointly, so itemising adds nothing unless other deductions already exceed the standard amount. If you do itemise, subtract your marginal rate multiplied by the interest from the buying line. At 24% on roughly $25,800 of first-year interest that is about $6,200 a year, which moves the break-even about one year earlier.
It moves out, sometimes by years, because the commission is charged on a lower price while the loan balance stays where it is. A 10% price drop in year five on the example removes about $52,000 of equity, more than the entire advantage buying had built by that point. That asymmetry is what the monthly comparison hides: renting has no exit cost, and a house sold in a bad year can cost more than a decade of rent differences.
No. The landlord pays those and the rent already contains them, so putting them on both sides double counts. The one cost worth adding to the renting column is renters insurance, usually $15–30 a month, plus any parking, storage or pet fee the lease charges separately rather than folding into the headline rent.
This one is free with no counter — the arithmetic runs in your browser and costs nothing to serve. All-Access is for the PDF and image tools, which are free three runs a day.